Christmas or Not

As our society increases in its secular observance of the "Holidays" are we approaching a combined "Christmahanakwanzika?" As Jews, how we we deal with good and the challenging about Christmas.


The discussion within Judaism regarding Christmas is a complex one.

Indeed, Jewish memories die hard.

Throughout our history, there has been little reason to be joyous on Christmas. Often, the celebrated birthday of the rabbi named Yeshua ben Joseph has provided an occasion for our gentile neighbors to exercise hostility towards our people. Pogroms and other massacres were not uncommon.

So, the message throughout our history on Christmas Eve has been "lay low."

Jews in Eastern Europe generally spent Christmas in the safety of their homes. In some locales, Christian authorities prohibited Jews from appearing in public. Often, Jewish schools and synagogues were closed. 

A tradition in the "old country" developed to play cards or chess on Christmas Eve. It even has a special name in our tradition, Nittel Nacht which is possibly an acronym for "Nolad Yeshu Tet L'tevet", meaning, "Jesus was born on the ninth of Tevet."

In modern times, some very unique Christmas related traditions have been adopted by American Jewry. These include going to the movies on Christmas Day, some rabbinically unauthorized trips to Chinese restaurants, or increasing volunteerism on Christmas Day -- enabling Christians to celebrate the holiday at home.

Some Jewish singles organizations hold dances known as Matzah Balls.

In Glen Cove, CTI has made it a tradition on Christmas Eve to order pizzas and deliver them both to the police station and to the fire house.

It is indeed a complex holiday. On one hand, it resonates within an older age group as a time of European persecution, harassment and discrimination, but for latter generations its recognition in some circles has become almost as American as Thanksgiving.

Increasingly, the holiday season has centered on thanking those who provide services during the years. These include letter carriers, and those who pick up our trash. It is a time to exchange presents with our non Jewish friends and neighbors, a time for parties, an occasion to reinforce ties with those of all faiths and beliefs, and to spread cheer.

It's hard to argue with that.

But in some ways, I find myself standing with traditionalists within the Christian community who bemoan the loss of the holiday's religious meaning. It has become so much about the showering of family and friends with materialism. 

I recall earlier in life as a newspaper publisher in northern Canada facilitating the singing of carols at Heritage Park in Fort McMurray, Canada, because I sensed people were not in the "spirit." It had nothing to do with endorsing Christmas' theological roots, but rather in my youthful arrogance trying to turn the kavanah (intention) of my readers towards a more spiritual plain.

There is nothing wrong with our encouragement of Christmas as a festival of peace and fellowship. For more important to us as Jews is the inclination of humankind towards repairing a broken world.

Yet there is a danger as we enter the season of winter solstice that Chanukah, Christmas and Kwanzaa will one day be morphed into a combined observance which some urban dictionaries already term Christmahanakwanzika.

And that for us is problematic.

For although on the surface these holidays appear to be similar, they are not.

And rather than trying to incorporate these holidays as one, we should be at least aware of, and embrace that each is different. We believe that God has no form and no physical needs. The idea of a "son of God" is problematic in Judaism.

Many schools within Judaism believe that a messiah, or anointed one, will arrive after humanity succeeds in creating a time of peace and harmony. The responsibility to perform Tikun Olam (repairing the world) is our obligation. Christian thought holds that the messiah has already walked the earth and will be returning to help restore order within an apocalyptic context. 

Kwanzaa, an  African-American festival established in 1967, focuses on seven core values which include unity, self-determination, collective work and responsibility, cooperative economics, purpose, creativity, and faith.

It is important that during this time of year, as always, we as Jews not only embrace our fellows, but also acknowledge our theological differences. It's what adds beauty to the world.

The great rabbi and founder of the Jewish Renewal movement Reb Zalman Schachter-Shalomi teaches that each religion on earth contributes a limb or organ to the body of humankind. There is so much to be learned from all faiths, and their religious and secular practices.

But let us also remember who we are as Jews: a unique people who carry a responsibility each day to heal a broken world. The term mitzvah does not mean good deed, rather it means commandment. And we are commanded to love our neighbor as ourself.

The great scholar Ben Azzai was asked almost two thousand years ago what the most important line of the Torah is. He referred to the Book of Genesis saying "we are all descendants of Adam." We are each made of the same stuff, the same hopes and the same dreams.

Let us as Jews find that balance between participating in a more ecumenical world and pursuing our own destiny. Let us also ensure that the scars we bear from the "old country" do not block our path towards a more universal, tolerant and peaceful path for humankind.

For this I believe is the true will of God.

Shabbat shalom. 

And happy holidays - wherever that sacred journey takes you.

Kol tuv (with all goodness)

Rabbi Irwin Huberman

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Jonathan Kavner December 27, 2012 at 07:02 PM
Let's not grossly generalize here. I'm a parent and I teach my child about her heritage. There are no Hanukkah bushes in our house and she learns the meaning of the holiday and not just an opportunity to get presents. We look forward to all our holiday traditions like singing songs, playing dreidel, lighting the menorah, latkes and sufignyot, spending time with family, hearing the story about how we rose up against our oppressors during difficult times, etc. Also your comments on how parents these days raise their children to never experience negativity or failure, leaving them unprepared for the real world is just another overly simplistic generalization used by older generations on a repetitive cycle over time. I am sure that your generation did everything right and all of us are just too lazy to put in the effort, but I would also bet that some of the generation that preceded you also thought you all sucked as parents.
Ralph Nesberino December 27, 2012 at 11:38 PM
Mr. Kavner, I certainly appreciate your concerns. However, you seem to be very defensive over generalized comments made. He was not referring to you in particular. Many groups of people are not dealt with fairly. Why continue referencing this injustice when notihng of this sort was mentioned. I would say don't take sayings of a stranger to heart. After a while it does leave a mark in your personality, which many people find distaseful. Bottom line, have a Happy New Year, and don't let trivial talk bother you.
Jonathan Kavner December 28, 2012 at 02:02 PM
Thanks for your input Ralph. I can assure you however, that I did not take Soup Nazi's comments personally, since they were not directed at me, personally. I did however, take offense as a member of two of the groups mentioned; parents these days and Jews. The use of my own personal examples was meant solely to offer up evidence that not "all" parents "suck." My issue isn't regarding anything that was directed at me (since none of it was), but more to the concept of generalizing groups. To me, "Parents these days suck" is a slippery slope away from "African Americans commit crimes," "Jews are cheap," etc. Maybe its just a different way of thinking; to castigate an entire group of people just seems, well, passe. But, maybe that's just the way the "older generation" does things ;) Happy New Year!
Yankee Man December 31, 2012 at 03:47 AM
Mr Kavner As a parent of children from 8 to 24 years of age, I can assure you you that by comments are based on my experience with parents over 20 years. We all know that todays helicopter parents or to involved parents are not always acting in the best interests of their child, but rather they ar emore concerned with making them happy. My parents, your parents and most parents of past generations were more concerned with many you into a useful citizen and a responsible adult. We didnt get a trophy for showing up, and my jewish friends parents were no going to celebrate Christmas or even santa Claus just to make them feel happy. Thats discipline
Jonathan Kavner December 31, 2012 at 02:51 PM
Sounds like the way we do things these days. Looks like we don't all suck. Happy new year!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »